Interesting - I was thinking about this as an option too and am glad to hear you've had good experiences with it. I have a bunch of roxul left over from a previous renovation, so I think I'll go this route and save myself a few bucks instead of doing the vermiculite. Did you cover the roxul with a lay of the fire blanket, or just leave it exposed? Given it's not loose like vermiculite, I'm thinking it would work without the need for a fire blanket.