Sounds like he saves all the little batches and then boils it together. So all of his bottles will be the same - the're the whole season together.
You on the other hand are bottling as you go. So the bottle you sampled is from a snapshot in time, not the average of the season.
I know my trees can produce very different syrup from batch to batch. Have you tried sampling other batches you made? It may be that most of your syrup is more similar to his, and the bottle you tried was an aberration.
If that's not it, I think Dr Tim's explanation makes the most sense: The very long batch boil (including continuous addition of new sap to the batch) would tend to make darker syrup. Combine that with the acidification in the fridge to lighten it, and maybe you get lighter-looking darker tasting syrup.
Gabe
2016: Homemade arch from old wood stove; 2 steam tray pans; 6 taps; 1.1 gal
2017: Same setup. 15 taps; 4.5 gal
2018: Same setup. Limited time. 12 taps and short season; 2.2 gal
2019: Very limited time. 7 taps and a short season; 1.8 gals
2020: New Mason 2x3 XL halfway through season; 9 taps 2 gals
2021: Same 2x3, 18 taps, 4.5 gals
2022: 23 taps, 5.9 gals
2023: 23 taps. Added AUF, 13.2 gals
2024: 17 taps, 5.3 gals
All on buckets